Scaling to 1 million websockets in PHP

14 Nov 2024 - by 'Maurits van der Schee'

A client asked me: How does one scale software to handle 1 million websocket connections? At 1000k connections when every client sends only one message per 30 seconds you have to deal with 33333 websocket messages per second. Dealing with that many requests per second is well understood in HTTP, but unfortunately these are messages on a websocket. Nevertheless, let's assume that these are HTTP requests for now.

33k requests per second in PHP

Laravel behind Nginx can do 2908 requests per second on a Dell R440 Xeon Gold + 10 GbE when the average API call is 20 database queries per request (see here). This means that in order to handle 33333 API requests for 1 million websockets you need a minimum of 12 of these machines. Also, the corresponding 666k queries per second may need horizontal scaling of the database (unless the queries are really cheap, see here).

Approximately 2 dedicated machines with Haproxy behind DNS round-robin may be able to handle the reverse proxy load of stripping SSL and distributing over multiple machines for about 33k HTTPS requests (see here).

DNS RR --> 2 x HaProxy --> 2 x WS2API --> 12 x PHP --> 2 x PgSQL

These 33k requests per second can be handled by 2 "WS2API" servers that convert websocket messages to HTTP requests.

How does WS2API work?

So what is this mythical WS2API project that allows one to treat websocket messages as HTTP requests?

WS client --[ws upgrade]--> WS server --[http get request]--> API server

WS client <--[ws connect]-- WS server <--[http response "ok"]-- API server

WS client --[message]--> WS server --[http post request]--> API server

WS client <--[message]-- WS server <--[http response]-- API server

And also:

API server --[http post request]--> WS server --[message]--> WS client

Note that responses to server-to-client requests are handled as client-to-server requests.

WS2API, complicated?

I have implemented WS2API several times in different languages and frameworks:

Go with GWS (source)
PHP with Swow (source)
PHP with OpenSwoole (source)

It is only 200 lines of code, so it is easy to port to any language/library. Here is a stress test (connection ramp-up) with 1 message per 10 seconds instead of per 30 seconds:

performance graph

As you can see the QPS (queries per second) and connection ramp-up are very good in Go, helping in cold-start situations.

A nicer diagram

WS2API diagram

Note that there is no centralized connection lookup needed as every requests is always (consistently) mapped to the same WS2API "ws proxy" server as long as each client connects with a unique "Client ID" string in the URI path. This ClientID is also used as an address when sending messages back to the websocket client.

Conclusion

If you want to deal with 1 million websocket connections it may be beneficial to convert the websocket messages to HTTP requests. This way you can deal with a "normal" high traffic web application, instead of a custom websocket solution. WS2API does this for you and WS2API as a concept that is easy to implement.

See: https://github.com/mevdschee/ws2api

Enjoy!

PS: Liked this article? Please share it on Facebook, Twitter or LinkedIn.

TQ
dev.com